I've carried S & W Model 19 snubnosed, Colt Detective Special, Several other S & W J-frame snubbies, a Charter Arms 44 Bulldog, even a Colt SAA "Sheriff's Model" in 44 spl. All had drawbacks, usually either weight, size, or capacity. The best was the Colt Detective Special (6 shots, +P and even ++P). The Detective Special was a surplussed security gun from the Lockheed "Skunk Works". Second were the "Humpback" S & W J-frames. However, I never shot them except at the range, although I did carry several daily after I got my CCW.